What Happens When You Interviewed Dr. Jekyll, But Hired Mr. Hyde?

Joe Smith (not his real name) is interviewing for a sales representative position with XYZ Manufacturing Company.

They ask him questions about his experience and background, and eagerness to sell. He shows enthusiasm and excitement for the job, and gives examples of successful past experiences.
Joe seems like a good fit, and he’s hired. But after a while, it becomes apparent that Joe’s not performing as he should.

He’s been given a quota of $500,000, but he’s only doing $300,000 in sales, despite the fact that he has a good territory and has undergone extensive sales training. His demeanor is relaxed and laid back, and he shows little passion or motivation.

What went wrong?

 

Bad hires = tons of hidden costs

I call it: “You interviewed Dr. Jekyll, but hired Mr. Hyde.”

The interviewee acted enthusiastic and excited, and gave examples of how he was successful, but he was playing the role of a passionate, energetic sales person like an actor in a play. This happens over and over at companies. Why? Because they hire the person who does the best interviewing — which I equate to acting — not the person who’s the best fit.

According to a 2012 article in Forbes titled, Hire for Attitude: An Interview with Mark Murphy, 46 percent of new hires fail within 18 months.

Bad hires create a myriad of hidden costs: Damaged relations with customers, lost business opportunities, high turnover rate with good employees, increased stress, time loss, and legal issues. Most studies say the average cost of a bad hire is 50-300 percent of a person’s salary depending on the specific position and level within the company.

One of the main reasons for this is that employers don’t know how to identify a person’s innate characteristics.
Identifying innate characteristics

Innate characteristics include traits such as assertiveness, extroversion, and detail orientation. These characteristics remain stable throughout a person’s life regardless of time and circumstances.

Non-innate characteristics can change with time and circumstances, and thus have far less ability to predict fit and behavior. Non-innate characteristics include attitudes, values, energy level and personal interests. These traits are important, but can change. They’re also easier to determine with good interview questions.

Unfortunately, interviews alone don’t identify innate characteristics. A high-quality, scientific-based assessment does, and can reduce employee turnover from 75 percent to 25-50 percent.

In an Inc. article titled, How to Hire Great People – Every Time, Les McKeown points out that managers should treat the hiring process “as the most important strategic planning your company needs.” The reason: Every new employee can either make or break a company. Managers need to hire employees who will help the company grow and become more profitable, not bring it down.
5 tips for hiring great people

McKeown listed four (4) tips. I’ve added some of my own thoughts and an additional fifth tip for hiring great people:

  1. Don’t ask crazy interview questions, like this one: “If you were a box of cereal, what would you be and why?” asked in an interview for a Bed Bath & Beyond sales associate. Google used to ask brainteaser interview questions. But last year, the company said they were no longer using them. “They don’t predict anything,” Google exec Laszlo Bock told The New York Times in June 2013. “They serve primarily to make the interviewer feel smart… Instead, what works well are structured behavioral interviews, where you have a consistent rubric for how you assess people, rather than having each interviewer just make stuff up.”
  2. Clearly define what it takes to be successful in the position. This includes identifying innate characteristics as well as experience, attitude, and values. Too often employers focus on job responsibilities or qualifications, not whether someone has the ability to do the job from the start. It’s important to focus on a person’s ability to do a particular job, since innate ability does not improve over time.
  3. Include an objective, science-based assessment to measure innate characteristics before engaging in the interview process. The interview process is inherently subjective; we’re human, and tend to hire people that we feel good about. Therefore, it is next to impossible to determine what someone is really like from interviews alone. Don’t waste your and the candidate’s time and effort when you have objective evidence that a person cannot succeed in your job and environment.
  4. Include others in the hiring process. Whether you’re working with a recruiter or not, it’s important to include all the people who will be interacting with the job candidate.
  5. There are literally hundreds of assessment tools, but many are outdated and focus on non-innate characteristics, which change over time. A great source of simple, practical and unbiased information that can help you make a wise decision can be found here.

Bad hiring can set a company back in many ways and result in financial and legal challenges. Using tools to find the right hire, on the other hand, can reduce employee turnover, putting your company on the path to growth and success.

 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Brad Wolff is Managing Director for JumpVine, an Atlanta-based recruitment firm.

SOURCE:

Brad Wolff (2015, February 17). What Happens When You Interviewed Dr. Jekyll, But Hired Mr. Hyde? Retrieved from http://www.tlnt.com/2015/02/17/what-happens-when-you-interviewed-dr-jekyll-but-hired-mr-hyde/

Announcement
Performance and Results Management (CESB Accredited Program)
July 25-26, 2019

Understand the discipline of having a systematic Performance Management System by learning how to plan, manage and monitor people performance, and provide timely, precise & accurate feedback to individuals and groups to improve individual, unit & organizational performance. Managing people’s performance is the key objective of establishing systematic performance management system in the workplace.  Performance […]

Building Powerful Teams (CESB Accredited Program)
August 8-9, 2019

Building powerful a powerful team is an essential tool of any successful and good company. When building a powerful team is done right, it is fun and it can help build camaraderie which is essential for a company’s success. Develop your team’s ability to better define objectives and goals, solve problems, resolve conflicts and trust […]

Transformational Leadership (CESB Accredited Program)
August 15-16, 2019

Transformational Leadership is to positively influence the organization. With the combination of right approach and talented employees, the potential of being a great organization is limitless. Positive transformation in an organization is always a good indicator of effective leadership. Learn and understand the basic concepts on being an effective leader. Understand how to help subordinates […]

Strategic and Critical Thinking (CESB Accredited Program)
August 29-30, 2019

Strategic and critical thinking is an essential factor for an organization to succeed. We make personal and professional decisions  everyday, not just hundreds but sometimes we make thousands and so on. In this program, learn to develop strategic and critical thinking that allows you to develop a plan of action designed in order to achieve […]

Problem Solving and Decision Making
August 28-29, 2019

Making effective and timely decisions can contribute to the proper execution of business strategy that ultimately leads to organizational effectiveness. To have this, managers and staff need to be equipped with the skills to decide quickly, implement these decisions and ensure that the implementation is flawless.     When done correctly, your organization and its […]

Driving Execution (CESB Accredited Program)
September 5-6, 2019

Driving Execution is very essential in the organization, implementing plans is very difficult as some are resistant to change.  In this program learn the art of implementing plans despite the numerous challenges that may arise and be skilled in understanding and coping with the dynamics of change to help you achieve organizational success.   Date: September […]

Coaching: Raising Performance to the Next Level (CESB Accredited Program)
September 12-13, 2019

Coaching is a training and development of a learner. Coaching is very important as it help to bridge the gap between education and work experience.  It is a way to develop the employees which can be vital in achieving goals. In this program, understand and apply the different styles of coaching. Boost your employees performance […]

Building a Culture of Innovation in the Workplace
September 16-17, 2019

Organizations (profit or non-profit) are facing change like never before. Driving forces to this change include a rapidly expanding marketplace (globalization), and increasing competition, diversity among consumers, availability of and accessibility to new forms of technology and even a changing workplace culture. Creativity and innovation are keys to the success of a business. Leaders need […]

Articles
Newsletter

Subscribe to receive our latest updates


View our clients’ testimonials